Microsoft Excel v. Microsoft Project v. Primavera P6

Jul 8, 2019 | News, scheduling

Executive Summary.  In the construction industry, there are three main tools used for scheduling.  Pros and cons of Microsoft Excel, Microsoft Project, and Primavera P6 are all briefly discussed.

The Three Main Options.  I still see schedules done on paper in the industry, and it works too, but here we review the three most common products in the industry.

Ideal Usage.  Paper and Microsoft Excel, frankly, aren’t that far apart.  This should be the minimal product you use and if this does the job and the client does not require you to “upgrade”, use it.

My rule of thumb has always been that Microsoft Project should be on every job of any size.  It’s powerful and simple to use.  It can be used as a true tool for superintendents and their staff.  It can be used by just about anyone – even your employees who can barely find the power button on their laptop.  Spend the couple hours teaching these less experienced users, it will empower them and serve a true function.

Primavera P6 is to be used when you have the skillset in house to use it right.  I’m not saying use every function in the software, but I am recommending you get basic training so that you can be proficient enough to use it effectively.  But, at the end of the day, if you must use it, hire it out to a professional and budget accordingly; scheduling services can be spendy.

My Story.  I’m strong at Microsoft Excel and pretty strong at Microsoft Project.  Primavera P6 is something I am weak in – I stopped my Primavera development at P3.  My recommendations are above.  The bottom line is that field ops should use Project on the job as a true tool – Primavera should be used to track larger projects globally once it’s tacked on the wall, and then as your Exhibit #1 in a claim situation. 


Recent Articles

Leave A Comment